Thursday, 6 September 2018

Four Days Before Christmas, 2017 - Part 5

As soon as the Christmas and New Year festivities were behind us, I set about finding a lawyer; I needed to find one fast. Because of the jurisdiction issues, the lawyer I employed really needed to be in Australia. I managed to find a lawyer who agreed to handle the matter for me, but the distance meant there were additional issues with time-differences, currency exchange, etc. The stress just never left me. Not even in my sleep. I had nightmares about stepping off a plane, going straight to court and then being handcuffed and marched to the cells, sobbing and protesting my innocence. I woke in a panic from my nightmares each time and realised I was actually in the middle of a real-life nightmare. I would feel my heart lurch and then hammer in my chest each time reality hit me, and the fear and stress would flood my body afresh. It was relentless.

My lawyer and I discussed me sending an initial letter to the Plaintiff’s lawyer, making it clear that I was not the person the Plaintiff was seeking, to see if this resulted in the Proceeding being discontinued.

I wrote to the Plaintiff’s lawyer on 2 January 2018. I advised that I was first alerted to the Plaintiff’s allegations upon receipt of the lawyer’s letters, and that I knew nothing about, nor was I responsible for, publishing any defamatory material about him. I confirmed that I was not aware of the Plaintiff’s address and had no interest in it, or in the Plaintiff.  I went on to say that the Plaintiff’s allegations were misdirected and that, had the Plaintiff (or the lawyer himself) written to me prior to issuing proceedings and provided me with an opportunity to respond to the Plaintiff’s allegations, the Plaintiff might have reached the same conclusion himself.

I pointed out that the defamatory material, if, in fact, it was actually published, could have been prepared by anyone with access to the internet. That the alleged author appeared to have referred to my name and to material published on the internet by others, including by me, did not determine the alleged authorship of the material. In any case, there was no link between the alleged defamatory material and my blog.

I advised that in my view there were a number of steps that the Plaintiff could have taken in order to ascertain the identity of the party responsible for the alleged conduct, which ought to have taken place prior to issuing a legal proceeding. In particular, I suggested that the Plaintiff could ask the owner of the internet domain to identify the IP address of the computer that was allegedly used to complete the Contact Us form entry.

I concluded the letter, politely suggesting that the Plaintiff refrains from wasting their money pursuing the wrong person, and I requested that the Proceeding be immediately discontinued.

On 10 January 2018, I received an email response from the Plaintiff's solicitor, in response to my letter. The lawyer requested that I provide a sworn Affidavit, deposing to the matters raised in my letter. He attached a draft Affidavit to his email and advised, “This may resolve the matter as far as you are concerned.” He instructed the Affidavit had to be witnessed by a Notary Public, here in the United Kingdom.

At this point, I parted with a large sum of money to my Australian lawyer for his assistance. He liaised with the Plaintiff’s lawyer in terms of agreeing the wording of the Affidavit. Its basic content had to include that whilst I was the named Defendant in the Proceeding, I had no knowledge of, nor had I published or authorised publication of any defamatory material about the Plaintiff.

The draft of the Affidavit prepared by the Plaintiff’s lawyer included a clause, which read: “I do not, and have never, believed or accused the plaintiff (either privately or publicly), of any conduct as referred to in the Email or the Letter.”

Of course, I have never accused the Plaintiff (either privately or publicly) of any conduct as referred to in the Email (meaning the Contact Us entry) or the Letter (meaning the posted material). I don’t know why they included a clause like this, because “belief” is subjective. As I understand it, an affidavit must be factual. I have no personal knowledge about the Plaintiff, including anything related to the allegations. I cannot say that I believe either way, as I have no idea. Some may say: “there’s no smoke without fire”, but I cannot comment as I don’t know. What was important, and necessary for the affidavit to include, was that I didn’t do it myself, nor authorise it, nor have any knowledge of it. 

Finally, the Affidavit wording was agreed and the clause about belief was removed from the final document.

I then parted with more money to a lawyer here in the UK, and on 31 January 2018, I affirmed the Affidavit before a Notary Public, as requested.

My Affidavit was submitted via my Australian lawyer, and I then had the stress of waiting to hear what the next move would be. I had gone to the trouble and expense of affirming the Affidavit, as requested by the Plaintiff’s lawyer, but there was absolutely no guarantee that that would be the end of the matter. As I understood it there was no legal obligation for the Plaintiff to cease the Proceeding against me if he chose not to. What if he decided to pursue me anyway?

On 1 February 2018, my lawyer notified me that the Plaintiff proposed to provide me with a release from participating in the Proceeding and for consent orders to be filed, which removed me from the Proceeding in the following form:

1.     Leave for the Plaintiff to amend the Statement of Claim to show the address of the Defendant as “unknown”
2.     The court to note that Marion Evans [from my address] is not the Defendant, Marion Evans
3.     The Proceeding to be deferred until 18 May 2018

So, bizarrely, the Defendant remained named as “Marion Evans”, but my address was removed, and the address of the Defendant was recorded as “unknown”. Thus, apparently leaving the Plaintiff to pursue another person using the name Marion Evans; although he had no idea who this was. Presumably, this would mean that anyone else on the planet named Marion Evans was now in the frame!

I had great difficulty in absorbing this; it just seemed ludicrous! I couldn’t understand why the Plaintiff couldn’t simply admit that he had made an error and pursued the wrong person. I’m sure the case could have been discontinued there and then. Instead, as I understood it, the Plaintiff was apparently considering proceeding with the case against the “correct” Marion Evans, the Marion Evans who had allegedly attacked him with defamatory material, the Marion Evans from an unknown address, not the Marion Evans from my address. I wondered how on earth he was hoping to find this other “Marion Evans”. In essence, it seemed he was proceeding with the case against an UNKOWN DEFENDANT. How on Earth could papers be served on someone unknown? I wondered if anything as bizarre as this had ever taken place in a court of law before. It seemed so unorthodox! If they ever did locate the author of the defamatory material, I am certain their name would not be Marion Evans! 

On 16 February, the date of the hearing, my lawyer emailed me, advising that the Court had adjourned the Proceeding for three months. He advised he had provided my affidavit directly to the Plaintiff's solicitor, who had supplied a Deed of Release for execution. I never signed the Deed of Release.

On 17 May, my lawyer emailed me with an amended Statement of Claim. My lawyer confirmed that I was no longer identified as the Defendant in the proceeding, and the relief that was being sought was not being sought against me. Instead, it was being sought against "a Marion Evans", whose address is "unknown" and the relief they were seeking was being sought against that person of unknown address, and not me, whose address they did know.

In June 2018, still with no idea what the exact position was, or what had transpired at the hearing on 18 May, I emailed the court to try to establish this. The court then responded with a copy of the court order that had been filed, which stated that the proceeding had been discontinued. Seemingly, the Plaintiff had not even deemed it necessary to notify me of this fact.

........Tomorrow: Medical diagnosis that turned my world upside down.


Wednesday, 5 September 2018

Four Days Before Christmas, 2017 - Part 4

Even though I had put the paperwork away until after Christmas, stressful thoughts invaded my mind every hour of every day. I thought about the way I was treated when the Exclusive Brethren took my mother from the UK to Australia, against her will (written about earlier in this blog), and I wondered if this organisation has a personal grudge against me. After all, it wasn’t only my name that was on the Contact Us form; there was also the Sun reporter’s email address. Yet it appeared that he was not also being pursued. This caused me to question whether bitterness towards me was the real motivation behind this defamation case against me.

On 27 December I returned to the Statement of Claim and went over it again and again. The Plaintiff alleged that I made the Contact Us form entry on a company website. I don’t know much about this sort of thing at all, but I’m pretty sure that there would have been a digital footprint left by the computer which had made the entry, by way of an IP address. This could surely have been traced by the website hosting company (or perhaps even by the police, especially given the nature of the alleged content) and if this were possible, it could probably have easily been established that the IP address that made the defamatory entry was not that of my computer. I thought this would have been the very first port of call, before issuing proceedings against me. This is certainly how I would have dealt with the matter, had I received a malicious entry on a website.

Then there was the alleged posting of the defamatory material at a post office on 18 December 2017, at, or around 6pm. In the UK this would have been 7am on the same day, and I would have been getting ready to start my day at home, in the UK. I was not in Australia at this time.

I wondered how the Plaintiff had come to know that the alleged defamatory material had been received and read by some of the local residents. Had a neighbour perhaps told him what had been received? Had the Plaintiff received a copy as well? I was curious to know.

I was now in a most unenviable situation. It seemed to me that hasty assumptions on the part of the Plaintiff had led to unsubstantiated allegations, without any proper investigation being carried out. It was obvious on several counts that the material was not instigated by me, and the Plaintiff had no firm foundation on which to base his allegations. This then begged the question: why on earth did the lawyer take it on? What sort of lawyer would take on a case such as this on the say-so of their client, with no evidence? Was this even ethical? If this is deemed good practice, then surely one person can accuse another of anything they like and take them to court, just on a whim. 

The first letter had advised that I was guilty of a criminal offence and that the police were investigating.

But, isn’t defamation a civil offence, not criminal? I decided to telephone Australian police in the relevant town; I told them that I understood an investigation was being carried out, in which I was apparently named, and that I wished to fully comply as I was an innocent party. The officer confirmed that, a) defamation was not a criminal matter, but a civil matter, dealt with through the courts, and, b) that they had nothing listed in either my name, the pseudonym the Plaintiff was sheltering behind, or the Plaintiff’s actual name.  The fact that the police said that they had no knowledge of investigating this case caused me to question the reference to a police investigation in the letter.

Apart from the fact that he is a member of the Exclusive Brethren, I know nothing about the Plaintiff and have no interest in him. I have no idea if the allegations are true or false and I have no interest in finding out. What I did know was that Plaintiff did not want to be identified. He used a pseudonym to protect his name, but dragged mine through the Australian court system, despite having no hard evidence against me. Some may say that by accusing me like this of perpetrating the defamatory material, the Plaintiff actually defamed me!

........Tomorrow: Instructing lawyers in both hemispheres, and a bizarre twist.


Tuesday, 4 September 2018

Four Days Before Christmas, 2017 - Part 3

I kept thinking about the person who had done this. Why had they used my name? Was someone deliberately trying to frame me? Was there someone 'out there, somewhere' who hated me, hated me enough to frame me, so that I would incur the wrath of the person who was being defamed? But, if someone was trying to frame me, why did they use mixed details; there seemed to be no explanation for those. At one point I even wondered if the Exclusive Brethren had tried to frame me. On the other hand, could this whole thing be a cry for help from someone? Nothing about this made sense to me.

It was alleged that the information on the Contact Us form was sent to the company website inbox at 10:42am on 17 December 2017. In the UK it would have been 11.42pm on 16 December 2017. I was fast asleep in my bed.

The personal details entered in the Contact Us form did not relate to each other in any way. The name “Marion Evans” was entered, but the email address was not mine; it was a Sun newspaper email address. The telephone number which started with 1300 was an Australian freephone or local number. 

After a simple Google search, it was apparent that the telephone number that had been entered was the number of the company named in the Proceeding, the company whose Contact Us form had allegedly been used to send defamatory imputations about the Plaintiff to the company email inbox. This was even more bizarre, and I failed to see the logic of concluding that this was my doing, purely on the basis of the name “Marion Evans” being entered. 

Apologies for the repetition, but just for clarity, the Contact Us form contained the following:

Name:              
Marion Evans

Email address:  

Phone:
Phone number of the company named in the Proceeding; the company to which it is alleged that defamatory imputations had been sent, via the Contact Us form.

Had any logic been used in deciding that I should be held accountable? I cannot help but think the answer to that is a resounding “NO”. I just could not understand how the Plaintiff had reached the conclusion that he had.

There were so many discrepancies. I acknowledge that my blog had been mentioned in the alleged defamatory material, and that my name had been used in the alleged Contact Us form entry. But as I have already stated, anyone could have done this. I therefore wondered why there was seemingly a knee-jerk reaction which resulted in court proceedings being issued, rather than either the Plaintiff or his lawyer contacting me to ask if I knew anything about it. For both parties, this would have been the cheapest option and the most civil of actions, rather than going to the expense of instructing a lawyer and submitting court papers. To me, this seemed an unnecessarily aggressive move, albeit in keeping with the litigious nature for which I understand that Exclusive Brethren are known. 

It then struck me, that maybe I wasn’t the only person to be served with court papers. Maybe the Sun reporter whose email address had been entered on the Contact Us form was also being pursued. That was an interesting thought; it would make sense if they were also in the frame, as the Plaintiff seemed to be largely led by the Contact Us form information. I looked back at the court papers, but there was no Co-Defendant named in the Proceeding, so I assumed that it was just me being pursued.

From the timeline below, please note the speed in which the decision was made to commence proceedings against me:

  • 17 December, it is alleged that the defamatory Contact Us form entry was received
  • 18 December, it is alleged that the defamatory material was posted
  • 19 December, it is alleged that some of the defamatory material was received and read by some of the residents
  • 21 December, I received a letter by email from a legal company, advising that steps were being taken to commence legal proceedings against me
  • 22 December, I receive a Letter of Claim by email, with a court hearing date set for 16 February 2018


The Plaintiff’s actions caused me a huge amount of distress; it was four days before Christmas. I know nothing about Australian Law, and I spent hours researching how to respond. I rang the Australian court, and the clerk advised that I was expected to be present in court, in Australia, on 16 February 2018, to defend myself. I was stunned; that couldn’t be right, surely?! 

The Statement of Claim instructed that I had 28 days from 22 December 2017 to file a Defence. This gave me until 19 January 2018, and with the Christmas and New Year shutdown in-between, there was really very little time to get matters moving. I was beyond stressed. I toyed with the idea of dealing with this myself, but I couldn’t possibly prepare a Defence and just up-sticks and fly to Australia in a few days’ time, especially with Christmas upon us. I feared that if I couldn’t attend court, or be represented, the court may enter judgment against me without further notice, and the result might even be a custodial sentence. All of this was like a heavy noose around my neck over Christmas and New Year. 

I put it all on hold for a few days and for the sake of my family, I put a smile on my face and decided to just “do Christmas”.

........Tomorrow: I question the real motivation behind this defamation case.




Monday, 3 September 2018

Four Days Before Christmas, 2017 - Part 2

The Letter of Claim alleged that the Plaintiff had been indulging in sexual misconduct with children (including his own), ran a network for this within a religious cult, covertly disguised as a Christian church, and that he was a predator of children (both his own and others), engaging in bribery and corruption to cover up his misdeeds.

The following pages contained scanned images of the alleged defamatory material. 

The “first matter complained of” was a screenshot of the “Contact Us” form entry. The name “Marion Evans” had been entered, together with the following email address, “X.XXXXX@the-sun.co.uk”, and a telephone number that started with 1300.

Inside the Contact Us enquiry box a few sentences were typed, in which the author threatened to expose the Plaintiff’s alleged sexual misconduct. The author stated their aim was to raise awareness of the situation, within the local community. The author claimed that the Plaintiff’s children had confided in a friend about their father’s behaviour. The author referred to the Plaintiff as a “predator” and a “pædophile hunter” who was targeting children in the community and claimed the Plaintiff would be exposed and stopped.

The entry was grammatically incorrect, with spelling mistakes (the wrong “there” had been used, it should have been “their”), poor paragraph composition and a reference to “incestuous pædophile hunters.” It was very weird.

The “second matter complained of” was set out over the next few pages and comprised scanned images of the material that had allegedly been sent in the post to neighbours of the Plaintiff.

There was a heading that was addressed to residents of an Australian street, asking if they knew their neighbours. Beneath the heading was a head and shoulders shot of the Plaintiff, with a warning triangle above it and the word, “DANGER”. Beside the picture was the Plaintiff’s name with the word,“PÆDOPHILE”, beneath it.

Next, was the name of my blog. This blog. Only it wasn’t the actual name as I had named it, it had been bastardised. Instead of, “Exclusive Brethren – Lies, Bribery & Deceit”, it read:

“Exclusive Brethren (Cult) – Incest, Paedophilia, Lies, Bribery and Deceit”

The additional words, “(Cult) – Incest, Paedophilia”, don’t, and never have, formed part of my blog title.

Thinking that my blog may have been hacked, I typed my blog name into the address bar of my computer and saw with relief that my blog was as I had named it; there was no evidence that it had been meddled with.

Next, was a very poor quality, grainy picture of what looked like a residential property. The caption alluded to this particular property being a venue for incest and child molestation.

Underneath the image was text that was similar to that which had been entered into the Contact Us form. Again, the phrase “Pædophile hunters” was used. Again, the content was grammatically incorrect. Again, the author seemed to be wanting to raise awareness in the community about who was living in the house.  The author made it clear that they (and seemingly the community too) did not want pædophiles in the vicinity. The author wrongly spelt the word “amongst”; instead, the letters the author typed spelt “amounst”.

This was not my work. I was indignant that the Plaintiff would think I had such a poor command of the English language.

The next three pages included an article by Michael Bachelard of the Sydney Morning Herald, it appeared to have been copied and pasted directly from the internet. It was headed:

“Potential witness in Exclusive Brethren sex abuse case paid to remain silent”


I knew of this article and had read it when it was first published. The above link had been pasted in various Facebook groups by Facebook-users, including me, in order to raise awareness.

The next page was headed:

“Unbelievable cruelty by a group who profess to be Christian.”

There was a picture of my mother and me together. The picture was taken when our family had found Mum in a hospital in Australia, in 2009; it features in Part 4 of this blog.

My blog address and the introduction to my blog had been copied and pasted into the document and I noticed that my blog address was not suffixed with “.uk”, as it would have been if I had copied and pasted it from the computer address bar, here, in England. Instead, it had another country’s suffix.

At the end of the document, the author of this material appeared to threaten that further material like this may be circulated at some future point

So that was it. I was accused of defaming someone. I had done nothing of the kind; I was totally innocent.

I felt angry and upset to be accused of this, but I also I felt very uncomfortable about what I had read. There was something odd about the author’s text composition; something strange about the naïve, almost childlike wording they had used.

Of course, the author may have deliberately written in such a manner in order to distract the reader and conceal the author’s identity, but my gut-feeling was, and still is, that this is the author's actual writing style. Why did the author use the words “pædophile hunter”? It didn’t make sense if they were implying that the Plaintiff was a child molester. A pædophile and a pædophile hunter were completely different. Who, and where was this person who had written this? It was glaringly obvious from the alleged defamatory text alone, that this was not my handiwork. Surely, if an expert compared the way I write with the way this was written, they would have drawn the conclusion that I was not the author of this material. In any case, doing something like this is simply not my style; I have written publicly about the Exclusive Brethren and my experience at their hands, but have only ever written factually, verifiable with a wealth of evidence.

........Tomorrow: Detailed timeline, which illustrates how quickly action was taken against me, with NO EVIDENCE.


Sunday, 2 September 2018

Four Days Before Christmas, 2017 - Part 1

Firstly, my apologies for the very long time that has elapsed since I have last written. Life has become extremely busy and I have not been able to complete this blog about the injustice of my mother being taken to Australia, and held there, despite her specific wish to return home. However, a far more detailed version of what happened will be included in my book, which I hope to complete when life slows down a little. 

Over the next few chapters I have documented the extreme distress to which I was subjected by an Exclusive Brethren member at the end of 2017, when I was notified of a defamation claim against me; I was being sued for something which I absolutely had not done. 

I recently notified the person who tried to sue me that I intended to blog what took place, and asked if he had anything to add. A few days later I received a response from his lawyer, in which I was threatened with further court proceedings if I published “any defamatory material about my client which you may be foolish enough to post on a blog”. 

I believe that freedom to tell our own personal story is a right which we all have, and so, after careful consideration, I have decided to go ahead as planned. My view is that there is no justification to pursue me through the courts once again, as I have taken great care to conceal the identity of the person concerned.

My account of events is factual, and it does not identify anyone associated with this matter in person, nor does it defame the Exclusive Brethren. 

Please note that the Exclusive Brethren recently rebranded as the Plymouth Brethren Christian Church, or PBCC. Whilst I note the organisation’s name change, for the purpose of this blog, where I need to refer to this group, I will refer to it by its former name, for consistency. 

I will try to keep this and the following chapters, brief and to the point; I think it is important that people know about this further injustice that took place. 

“If you are neutral in situations of injustice, you have chosen the side of the oppressor.”
Desmond Tutu


*  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  * 


On Thursday 21 December 2017, when I awoke, I received an email from a legal firm in Australia, with an attached letter. 

The contents of the letter advised that their client had become aware of material sent by mail to residents of an Australian street, which apparently contained grossly offensive, false and highly defamatory allegations against their client. I was put on notice that it is an offence under section 471.12 of the Commonwealth of Australia Criminal Code to use a mail service to menace, harass or cause offence, with a maximum term of imprisonment of two years, and that “my” conduct in sending this material in the mail constituted a criminal offense; it had been reported to the police, who were investigating. The letter went on to advise they had taken steps to commence defamation proceedings against me in an Australian court, in which they would be seeking substantial damages and costs. 

Apart from recognising the name of their client as a member of the Exclusive Brethren, I had absolutely no idea to what the letter referred; I was very miffed. 

There was no demand for me to respond by a deadline and I had not sent defamatory mail to anyone. Concluding that it must be a mistake, or some kind of scam or rogue mail, I decided to put it out of my head. 

The following day, Friday 22 December, I received another email from the same legal firm in Australia. The subject heading was: 

“XXXXX -v- Marion Evans in the [Australian Court], Case No: 2017/XXXXX” 

As soon as I read the subject heading I realised that this was serious. This was not spam, or a mistake. Someone had issued court proceedings against me. 

The email had two pdf documents attached. 

The first was a letter informing me that the legal firm acted for the Plaintiff, who, in order to conceal his identity, used a pseudonym for the purpose of the court proceeding. By way of service, they had enclosed a copy of a sealed Statement of Claim, as filed in court on 22 December 2017. A “First Directions Hearing” was listed for 16 February 2018 at 09:30. The Plaintiff had been permitted by the judge to file a Statement of Claim under a pseudonym and also granted leave for it to be served via email, which is not the normal practice for service, as I understood it. 

The second document was the Statement of Claim, comprising 22 pages. I was referred to as the “Defendant”, and the Plaintiff was claiming damages from me, as well as costs and interest, and an order that I be permanently restrained from publishing what were referred to as “the first and second matters complained of”. 

In a nutshell, the Statement of Claim alleged that I had either authored, or used an agent to author, information that had been entered into a “Contact Us” form on an Australian company website, which had been sent to the company email inbox on the morning of 17 December 2017. It also alleged that a publication was sent via the postal system, on or about 18 December 2017 at around 6pm, which was read by some residents on 19 December 2017. 

The alleged defamatory material that was emailed to the company website and the alleged publication that was sent through the post carried defamatory imputations related to the Plaintiff.

........Tomorrow: Details of the allegations against me.